My first thought was "What's going on here?", when a drop of water hit me from above. I looked up to see additional water droplets hanging from the exhaust fan directly overhead.
It was raining outside and entirely logical that we had a new leak at the roof. I began to think the worst. Nervously, I couldn't decide whether to go to the attic or the roof? I wondered if maybe the gutters were full of leaves and water was backing up under the shingle and somehow traveling to the exhaust fan. Leaks can be very elusive, and sometimes just impossible to locate their origin. I proceeded to the roof, surveying the laminated shingles, only 10 years old, around the area of the vent. Everything looked fine. Nothing out of the ordinary.
I quickly proceeded into the attic and over to the suspect area. Sure enough, water was pooling in the fiberglass batt insulation directly above the bathroom vent fan. As I traced the path of the water by reviewing the wet insulation, I realized the water was traveling into the attic from the area of the bath exhaust fan vent pipe. I had the presence of mind to bring a towel with me and soaked up as much water as I could. However, the lingering question, "What do I do now?"
Grab a tube of caulk? Oh, that would be so easy - but no, I just can't. As a home inspector, I've said it too many times, "...if the flashing is caulked, that's considered a temporary repair..." If I found a caulked repair during an inspection, I would make note of it in the report and recommend a permanent repair by a professional contractor. Why? Well, the mere presence of caulking frequently implies previous leaking issues, and the right thing to do is not just treat the symptom, but attempt to determine the origin. However, that's easier said than done in many cases. The right diagnosis and repair takes time.
As a home inspector, my answer of how to repair a leak is clear, but as a homeowner taken off guard by this leak, on a very busy day (as is always the case), am I starting to waiver? I can't be late to my next appointment, and I don't want anymore water accumulating on my floor or ceiling! I don't have time to casually "find a professional contractor". And if there's one thing my past experience as an insurance property adjuster has taught me, it's that water damage is the worst, and quick to destroy!
Okay, calm down. Take a deep breath. Remember, you're a trained home inspector. You see this stuff all the time. You know what it takes to fix this problem. No caulk. No temporary repairs. This leak needs attention. Get busy. Call a professional.
"Hello, ABC Roofing? Thanks for answering the phone. You see, I have this puddle in my daughter's bathroom, water is dripping from the ceiling, need a repair fast, and ........"
Fast forward several hours, problem resolved. Below is a snapshot of the repair that was made to the roof. Ah, now I feel better. ---Wait, is that caulk?...........






Installation went off without a hitch. The contract installer thanked us and went on his way. My wife and I eagerly anticipated throwing in the first load of clothes. "But wait," I said, "Shouldn't we remove this bright yellow Energy Guide/Energy Star sticker adhered to the top of the washer in plain sight for all the world to see?" I proceeded to carefully remove the label and immediately noticed a very thick and very stickly glue residue remaining from where the label had been attached. Hmmm. What to do?

Many years ago, I had a trainee with me doing a trainee ride-along (let’s just call him Keith, partial ID to protect those who have gone on to greater things). The inspection was going along very well. The clients decided to stick with me (I prefer that), and were taking notes as well.